OR/16/029 Appendix 2 - Final agenda

Pearce, J M, Akhurst, M C, Jones, D G, Vincent, C J and Booth, J H. 2016. Pathways from pilot to demonstration: How can research advance CO2 geological storage deployment? (Energy and Marine Geosciences Programme) British Geological Survey External Report, OR/16/029.

BRITISH GEOLOGICAL SURVEY AND UK FOREIGN AND COMMONWEALTH OFFICE CO₂ STORAGE WORKSHOP

Pathways from pilot to demonstration: How can research advance CO₂ geological storage deployment?

1–3 March 2016, British Geological Survey (BGS) Keyworth, near Nottingham, NG12 5GD, UK

Workshop objectives:

• Examine how pilot, field lab and lab projects can inform and advance large‐scale storage
• Reinforce importance of advancing CCS through practical experience at varied relevant scales: pilots/field labs (testing concepts) and demonstrations (deploy technologies and identify new technical questions for pilots to examine)
• Strengthening international links between field lab, pilot, demo and large scale project operators to make it easier to share lessons learned
• Exchange research learning between CCS and other geo‐energy disciplines

Workshop outcomes:

• Identification of opportunities for collaboration and development of outline proposals to advance CCS and geo‐energy research through practical experience and demonstrations.

Workshop programme

Starting with lunch on 1 March and finishing after lunch on 3 March 2016

Day 1:	Tuesday 1 March 2016
11:30	Free coach transport departs Jurys Inn hotel, Nottingham for BGS Keyworth
12:00	Registration and lunch at BGS Keyworth

Session 1: Sharing practical experiences of the role of research and international learning to
inform deployment of CO₂ storage
Advancing CCS through practical experience at varied relevant scales, i.e. test sites and pilot projects (testing concepts) and demonstrations (deploy technologies and identify technical questions for pilot projects to examine).

Each speaker 15 minutes maximum plus five minutes for questions.
Chair: Andy Chadwick, BGS

12:50	Welcome	Jonathan Pearce, BGS, Team Leader CO2 Storage
13:00	Introduction and aims of the workshop	Mike Stephenson, BGS, Director of Science and Technology
13:10	Research drivers for large-scale deployment of CO2 storage: Norway perspective	Phillip Ringrose, Statoil
13:30	The Aquistore project and its relevance to large scale storage in Canada	Kyle Worth, PTRC
13:50	Keynote: CCS activities in Shell and research needs for large‐scale implementation	Andreas Busch, Shell
14:20	STEMM‐CCS monitoring of an offshore CO2 release	Jerry Blackford, PML
14:40	Offshore CO2 storage in South Korea: R&D progress and future plans	Sang Hoon Lee, KIOST
15.00	Carbon capture and storage in South Africa: mandate and progress	Tony Surridge, SACCCS
15:20	ECCSEL: European Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage Laboratory Infrastructure	Sverre Quale, ECCSEL
15:40	Refreshments and workshop photograph

Session 2: Exchange of learning between CCS and other geo‐energy sectors
Each speaker 20 minutes including five minutes for questions.
Chair: Lee Spangler, Montana State University

16:00	Research in the hydrocarbons sector relevant to CO2 storage	Bob Gatliff, BGS, Science Director of Energy and Marine Geoscience
16:20	Integrating research for geo‐energy and CCS by ESIOS (Energy Security & Innovation Observing System for the Subsurface UK)	Mike Stephenson, BGS, Director of Science and Technology
16:40	Discussion
17:40	Close

17:40	Informal networking drinks reception at BGS (includes 15 minute briefing of breakout group chairmen and rapporteurs).
18.40	Free coach transport departs BGS to Jurys Inn hotel, Nottingham Selection of suggested restaurants for informal dining in Nottingham. ‐‐oo000oo‐‐

Day 2:	Wednesday 2 March 2016
08:00	Free coach transport departs Jurys Inn hotel for BGS Keyworth

Session 3: Active test sites and pilot projects — opportunities for collaboration
Each active site or project 15 minutes maximum plus five minutes for questions.
Chair: Dave Jones, BGS

08:45	Welcome, introduction and aims	Jonathan Pearce
08:50	Geoenergy Test Bed, UK field lab site — a fluid flow field laboratory, Nottingham, UK	Ceri Vincent, BGS
09:10	The Sulcis CCS project, Italy: the characterization phase	Alberto Plaisant, Sotacarbo
09:30	Hontomín Pilot Site (Spain). CO2 injection in a carbonated deep saline aquifer	Carlos de Dios, CIUDEN
09:50	Potential of robust trend analysis methods for long‐term CO2 leakage predictions: A case study based on a controlled shallow CO2 leakage site in Korea	Eungyu Park, K‐COSEM Research Center and Kyungpook National University
10:10	Pilot sites in the Pohang Basin, Janggi Basin and Youngil Bay, South Korea	Insun Song, KIGAM
10.30	Refreshments

Chair: Jonathan Pearce, BGS

11:00	Guangdong CCUS project, China	Liang Xi, UK‐China (Guangdong) CCUS Centre
11:20	Pilot project(s) in China	Xiaochun Li, IRSMCAS
11:40	Nagaoka Project, Japan and its collaboration opportunities	Ryozo Tanaka, RITE
12:00	Tomakomai pilot project, Japan, and its collaboration opportunities	Jun Kita, RITE
12:20	CaMI.FRS: a field research station monitoring test site, Alberta, Canada	Don Lawton, Containment and Monitoring Institute
12:40	Lunch

12:40

Lunch at BGS Keyworth

Session 3 continued

13:30	Ginninderra controlled release facility, Australia	Andrew Feitz, Geoscience Australia
13:50	Developments and opportunities at the CO2CRC Otway project, Australia	Charles Jenkins, CO2CRC

Session 4: Breakout sessions
Discussion groups to identify research topics with benefit across projects and disciplines and prospective upcoming funding calls in respective areas and nations.

14:10	Introduction to breakout group sessions	Jonathan Pearce
14:20	Group 1: Collaboration between projects and across disciplines on Deep monitoring and injection optimisation and other geo‐energy resources	1A, Chairman — Charles Jenkins Rapporteur — Jim White, BGS
		1B, Chairman — Ceri Vincent Rapporteur — Ton Wildenborg, TNO
	Group 2: Collaboration between projects and across disciplines on Shallow migration/ leakage monitoring, environmental impacts & remediation and other geo‐energy resources onshore	2A, Chairman — Dave Jones, BGS Rapporteur — Matt Hall, GERC/BGS
		2B, Chairman — Kyle Worth Rapporteur — Andrew Feitz
	Group 3: Collaboration between projects and across disciplines on Shallow migration/ leakage monitoring, environmental impacts & remediation and other geo‐energy resources offshore	3A, Chairman — Jerry Blackford, PML Rapporteur — Karen Kirk, BGS
		3B, Chairman — Andy Chadwick, BGS Rapporteur — Sue Hovorka
15:20	Refreshments

Session 5: Plenary on outcomes from breakouts — identified topics and opportunities for mutually beneficial collaboration

15:50	Introduction	Jonathan Pearce
16:00	Feedback from Group 1A	Jim White
16:10	Feedback from Group 1B	Ton Wildenborg
16:20	Feedback from Group 2A	Matt Hall
16:30	Feedback from Group 2B	Andrew Feitz
16:40	Feedback from Group 3A	Karen Kirk
16:50	Feedback from Group 3B	Sue Hovorka
17:00	Summary of outcomes from breakout groups — group discussion	Maxine Akhurst, BGS
17:40	End of day 2

17:45	Free coach transport departs BGS to Jurys Inn hotel, Nottingham
19:30	Free coach transport departs Jurys Inn hotel, Nottingham to Trent Bridge Cricket Club for dinner
22:30	Free coach transport departs from Trent Bridge to Jurys Inn hotel ‐‐oo000oo‐‐

Day 3:	Thursday 3 March 2016
09:00	Free coach transport departs Jurys Inn hotel, Nottingham, for BGS Keyworth

Session 6: Next research steps from demonstration along the path to deployment
Chair: Bob Gatliff, BGS, Science Director of Energy and Marine Geoscience

09:30	Review of outcomes from breakout groups	Jonathan Pearce
09:40	Perspective on collaboration to share research learning — lessons learned from international experience	James Craig, IEAGHG
10:00	Feedback from storage project developers and operators on breakout group outcomes, ensuring relevance to demonstration and deployment	Industry panel — BP, CCSA, Guangdong CCUS project, Lundin, Pale Blue Dot (Caledonian Clean Energy), Shell, Wright Energy Solutions Ltd,
11:00	Refreshments
11:30	Discussion Identification of concrete opportunities for collaboration between test sites, pilot projects and deployment Outline concepts for proposals to implement the research collaboration opportunities	Maxine Akhurst, BGS
12:30	Summary of next steps	Jonathan Pearce
12:45	Meeting close

12:45	Lunch at BGS Keyworth
13:30	Free coach transport departs from BGS Keyworth to Jurys Inn hotel, Nottingham

Tours of the BGS geological walk, 3D visualisation suite and core store, approximately 20 minutes duration, can be arranged after lunch for those who wish. Delegates are welcome to remain on the BGS campus to undertake the short tours which will be arranged as requested.